
Photograph by Katie Vanderhaeghe, Sweater Eyes. Click to enlarge.
Ella’s over to play, even though we’re only friends some of the time. But she lives down the block, so if there’s nobody else around we’ll play together. Once I threatened to punch her in the stomach because she was bugging me, and she ran home to tell on me so fast that my mom was waiting, really angry, on my front porch. Ella’s mom had already phoned.
Anyway, she’s over and her tooth is loose—her bottom one to the left—and we decide that we should yank it out and then try to catch the Tooth Fairy that night. She could be our secret friend. Well, first we have to get out the tooth and convince our moms to let us have a sleepover.
Ella sits on the toilet seat while I wrap her loose tooth with a Kleenex and try wiggling it in her open mouth.
She looks up at me with doe eyes that I really can’t stand.
“Ez et oerking?” she says.
“Yeah, I think so,” I tell her, twisting the tooth a little. Ella winces a little and I let up, watching her squirm and then regain composure, her jaw hanging slack. The Kleenex is getting a bit bloody.
Whatever. I’m the one pulling it out, not feeling the pain.
I twist the tooth again, stronger this time—and let up again immediately. Coax it along.
“What are you two doing?”
My mother’s standing in the bathroom doorway.
“My tooth is loose!” Ella says gleefully.
My mom narrows her eyes and asks if we’re twisting it. We say no, and ask if Ella can sleep over.
“Please, mom, please? We’ll be good!”
“I’ll call my mom and ask!”
“No,” mom says, “I’ll phone your mom and ask.”
We all smile innocently at each other and then mom goes back downstairs. As soon as we hear her start talking, Ella opens her mouth again, and I go in for the kill.
“Ohhwww.”
Success!
Ella grins with a gap, eyes shining, blood dribbling down her chin, and the tooth in a soggy tissue. So far so good. Ella runs to the top of the stairs and yells down at my mom that her tooth came out, will the tooth fairy know to visit me here?
Ella goes home shortly after that to collect her overnight bag. My mom and I put a fresh spread on my top bunkbed after clearing off all the stuffed animals. There are a lot. I have a collection. I don’t like sleeping far off the ground, which is kind of funny considering I have a bunk bed and most kids like to be up high. I like to climb trees, but other than that, no thanks.
Anyway, my mom and I finish making up my room and then go downstairs to make supper, me plotting all the while.
*
After dinner Ella and I write down the plan in my notebook. It’s from Thrifty’s and is made from the seat of a pair of blue jeans. The pockets hold pens and notes and really any kind of paper you want to hide in there. It’s pretty cool. My older sister has one too.

“We need to make a house for her to stay in,” I say. We’re sitting on my bedroom floor, on the rug with a howling wolf on it. My door is closed.
“It should have a lid so she can’t fly out.”
“She’s not a prisoner.”
“I know.”
We both look around the room but see nothing that would be a suitable house—any kind of container big enough for a fairy.
“How big do you think she is?” I ask.
Ella stops looking around and sits still for a second. “Um, probably pretty big, cuz she has to carry teeth.”
“That makes sense.”
We get up and go to the playroom. There’s lots of stuff in there—there has to be something for a house.
In the bottom of the games closet, under a basket of plastic dinosaurs, there’s a square, pink box with a snap-on lid. It’s pretty big.
“How’bout that?” I point, but Ella’s already working on weaselling it out. We take the blue box and the tub of Barbie clothes back to my room. Before shutting ourselves away again, I look in the craft cabinet at the top of the stairs. My mom has spent years collecting the soap beds from her Clinique face soap, saving them in case she ever builds a dollhouse that requires tiny green beds. I find the box of soap beds—far too many of them, holy moly—and choose the largest. I also find some foam scraps to use as a mattress.
Back in my bedroom, we’re picking out pretty Barbie clothes to offer to the Tooth Fairy and decorating the empty inside of the blue box “house.” We layer the bottom with a nicely folded scarf my mom bought me from a global goods store. It’s pure silk, I think.
There’s a knock on my door. It’s mom.
“What are you girls doing?” she asks.
“We’re going to catch the Tooth Fairy tonight!” we tell her excitedly, each interrupting the other as we explain how we’re going to hide Ella’s tooth so that the Tooth Fairy won’t know where it is right away. Then we’re going to fake sleep. When she flies into the room, I (on watch) will signal to Ella who’ll throw down a blanket to cover the fairy. Then we’ll shut the window and try to convince her to stay. We’ll show her the house we set up and the clothes we’ve picked out for her—some really pretty dresses, shoes, and capes. And we’ll tell her how nice we are and how close we both live—just down the block from each other—which means Ella can visit and play all the time.
I never mention that I don’t really like Ella all that much and probably won’t have her over again, which means that I get to play with the magical Tooth Fairy all by myself.
My mom might suspect this, which is why when we’re finished telling her about our plan, she raises her eyebrows and says, “Really? Great.” She sounds a little tired and looks at me funny. She tells us to have fun and then leaves.
*
Ella and I are “ready” for bed—meaning that we told my mom no, we weren’t going to stay up all night long, that we were going to go to sleep. As soon as my mom says goodnight and leaves, we whisper in the dark to each other:
“I’ll keep watch.”
“I won’t fall asleep, don’t worry.”
We are both so intent, believing so honestly that we can actually catch this secret dream.
*
We both fall asleep.
And in the morning, Ella looks under her blanket at the foot of the bed, where she hid her tooth, and there a shiny Loonie wrapped up in the Kleenex instead of Ella’s gross little tooth.
“You fell asleep!”
“So did you!”
I shrug. “There are other chances, I guess.” More of Ella’s teeth I could pull out, if I could stand her.
“We better go show your mom and dad, I guess.”
Downstairs, even though we’re slightly disappointed and a little annoyed with ourselves for falling asleep, mom’s chocolate chip pancakes in animal shapes cheer us up. By the end of breakfast, we’ve lost interest in the Tooth Fairy endeavour all together.

Photograph by Katie Vanderhaeghe, Sweater Eyes. Click to enlarge.
Look at this scrawl. The plan.
And yet, it is only now, after all these years, that I realize we didn’t write down Catch the Tooth Fairy, the most important part of the whole operation. A rather vital step, don’t you agree?

Photograph by Katie Vanderhaeghe, Sweater Eyes. Click to enlarge.
Share this post with friends and strangers:
Like this:
One blogger likes this post.